Monday, 30 April 2012

Dissertation - Design & accessibility

Dissertation

- 6000-8000 word dissertation (aim for the upper word limit)
- Broken down into 4 chapters - 4 x 1500 word essays
- Think of a theme with a series of sub-theme you wish to investigate
- Coherent, organised and critical approach
- Ensure you include as much (relevant) primary research as possible

Methodologies

- Feminist, semiotic, psychoanalytical, marxist, ecological, postcolonial, narratology etc
- Theoretical way to look at a give subject
- Different lenses on a given topic will yield different results - how will you address it?
- Uniformed methodology

Primary research

- Interviews (with designers, the public etc)
- Questionnaires (if thought through and rigorous)
- Own analysis on works of design
- TV / Film / Animation
- Archives

CHECK VLE FOR RESOURCE


Design and Accessibility

Relationship between the designer and the audience and how this manifests itself
Communication - how people negotiate meaning

A -----> B    Process / Linear model

How much does the designer consider the audience when designing?
How much does the audience understanding what the designer is trying to communicate?




The problem with process models are that they are linear / one-way
They don't understand that communication derives from both sources
Doesn't take into account the audience as a creator of meaning

A <-----> B

Be aware of the linear way of communication and semiotic theory
Communication within a social structure
Dependent on a sociopolitical context


Audience theory

- Models have emerged on the concept of semiotics that focus on audience
- Class, race, sex, gender etc
- Many of these issues are sometimes ignored by the designer
- Some designers see audience as a homogenous mass - same thoughts, ideals, aspirations
- Audience theory intends to abolish this

A, B, C1, C2, D, E - one way of 'categorising' an audience

Starts to look at social context creating communication as much as the designer

Frankfurt School

Adorno reduces society as one pliable mass of people without difference
Overestimates the power of the media

Effects model / Hypodermic syringe

Communication systems - mass media 
Hypodermic syringe that 'injects' the mass audience


Reception theory 

Similar to audience theory
Shows how meaning is created at the point of reception by the individual based on own circumstances
Meaning is not created in one source and transmitted (Shannon & Weaver)

David Morley (1980)

1) Preferred reading (dominant hegemonic)
- When you are sent a message by an advertisement, you are taking a preferred reading
- The message intended by the designer

2) Oppositional
- Opportunity for the same advert meaning something else to someone else

3) Negotiated
- Not accepting the dominant / preferred reading but don't totally oppose it either


Uses & Gratification model

- Extension on reception theory
- Emphasises that people use the media for their own ends, they are not manipulated
- Meaning of the media depends on the person - constantly shifts

THE DEATH OF THE AUTHOR (Roland Barthes)




Initial idea: Semiotics & myth in relation to logo and branding in its simplest form

Thursday, 26 April 2012

Dissertation Lecture

Extended written essay on one topic
In-depth critical research and analysis
6000-8000 words

HE Courses - Cross College - Level 6 Dissertation
Existing powerpoint presentations

Proposal forms online - ensure details are correct


Academic support - G23 (3 opportunities)

One next week, another in September - first come, first serve
Not about context but expression  how you communicate through your writing

The dissertation...


It is not just a descriptive piece of work
Think analytically
Be enthusiastic

It is a common mistake to choose a broad topic - it is essential the topic is relatively narrow
Choose the best topics that will inform your argument / standpoints
Start collecting information that is relevant to your particular interest
It will feed into your studio practice - needs to have relevance

Marking

Marked against a clinical mark scheme
Use a breadth of sources - they mark against this (books, magazines, journals, exhibitions, web etc)
How have you collected evidence from these sources? What is important?

Research

The collection of information is the key to a stress free project
E-mail / write letters to companies
Dissertation tutorials with supervisor

Proposal

Ensure the title is clear and explanatory
What primary sources will you use? First hand interaction
Have some sources prepared for the dissertation proposal
Don't click submit if it is not 100% correct - draft first